Winter Coat Poll

I need your help.  Winter is around the corner and I am dire need of a coat that can withstand the cold (or close to it, at least).  I've narrowed my choices down to two.  Please help me pick!!! 

Choice 1: Liric in Grey - with a removable faux-fur hood

Choice 2: Down coat with arm warmers (to be worn with a snood or a trapper hat)

Thanks for your help!  xoxo